The Mario Blog

12.20.2023—3am    Post #22460
Artificial Creativity: does AI offer it?

We continue to explore this fascinating topic. How much creative intelligence can we expect from AI? Perhaps it can inspire us, but it takes the human creative touch and journalistic savvy to complete the concept?

The more I get engaged with AI, and, as I read daily reports about AI— the often good, the sometimes bad and the occasionally horrific stories that are like flashing green and red lights in my email– the more that I ask myself many questions about the creative potential of the bots. One topic that resonates with me is that of artificial creative intelligence.

As readers of TheMarioBlog know, I often indulge in these discussions via comparisons of what a human illustrator has done for a specific story in a particular publication, and what my friendly robot would do given the same material. Recently, one of my posts asked :

Artificial Creative Intelligence-is there such a thing?


I do not have an answer, so what I do is to engage in exercises that allow me and you to see comparisons. This blog post today is a continuation of that.

“Who wore it best?”

Disclaimer: I admit that my inspiration for these comparisons of humans versus bots comes from People magazine’s occasional feature titled, Who Wore it Best, where the editors place the images of two celebrities side by side wearing the same outfit. The readers decide. Here is an example:

Let’s do the same here, as I take two stories from this week’s New York Times that used illustrations.

Story 1–

What’s Your ‘Biological Age’?

New tests promise to tell you if you have the cells of a 30-year-old or a 60-year-old. Here’s what to know about them.

Above, the illustration created by Mike Ellis for The Times.

The prompt for Midjourney: Poster illustration with colors orange, skin tones, blue background for story: What’s Your ‘Biological Age’? New tests promise to tell you if you have the cells of a 30-year-old or a 60-year-old. Here’s what to know about them. Old versus young profiles. Clock marks how time affects our bodies.

The Midjourney results:

Perhaps a bit busy, but it is interesting to notice that both, the human illustrator and the bot, placed the clock as the centerpiece of the illustration.

Here the essence of the story is not immediately conveyed: this could be about relationships, for example, but not necessarily about aging. Artistic, yes, journalistic illustration, not for this particular story.



Same as image 2, an artistic rendering that does not tell the story. Perhaps the clock or clock hands in the center would help.  The question: isn’t that where the human illustrator come in? This image could inspire the artist to add touches that would contribute to tell the specific story which the art accompanies.


Story 2

The Case of the Never-Ending Illness

Post-pandemic, winter has become one big blur of coughs and colds. Did something change?

The prompt: Collage illustration for newspaper for story with headline The Case of the Never-Ending Illness Post-pandemic, winter has become one big blur of coughs and colds. Did something change? Use pills, tissues, people blowint their noses, droopy eyes, cold misery, colors orange, pink, yellow blue, pastels

The Midjourney results:


Colorful, artistic, but much less direct than the original created by a human artist.
Colorful but more journalistically sound in terms of conveying the meaning of the story through details.
Not very direct: could be about winter-time depression, for example.


So, who wore it best?

I suggest you take a few minutes to go to answer the question, providing rationale for your choice. Have fun. And, remember, the question continues:

Artificial Creative Intelligence-is there such a thing?

Midjourney, left; The New York Times right.



Midjourney, left; The New York Times right.

Media predictions for 2024

Every year, Harvard University’s Nieman Lab publishes what selected media people predict for journalism in the following years. You can find my own prediction here;

https://www.niemanlab.org/2023/12/ai-takes-center-stage/

Of interest!

https://new-world-encounters.com/blog/2022/02/21/secrets-to-successful-mobile-storytelling-interview-with-visual-storyteller-mario-garcia/

https://history.siia.net/amp/Publications/Blog/Index/Post/81144/Presenting-Information-in-the-Best-Way-It-Will-Be-Consumed-AM-P-2020-Keynote-Mario-Garcia-Wants-Stories-Designed-for-Todayt

How we use AI

Honored to be mentioned here:

https://www.newsroomrobots.com/p/how-10-news-industry-leaders-use

Pre-order my new AI book here

https://thaneandprose.com/…/preorder-ai-what-to-expect…

Here is a chance to pre-order my new book about Artificial Intelligence and content creation. The first 25 copies sold will be signed! Order here:

https://thaneandprose.com/…/preorder-ai-what-to-expect…

Pre-publication reviews!

AI front and center

As I put finishing touches on the manuscript of my new book, AI: The Next Revolution for Content Creation, I am aware that the number of AI-related headlines that appear in my mailbox daily is on the increase, frustrating the author of a book that must have a date of completion, and realizing that in today’s fast paced technological advance environment, books must have websites created for updates.

For more about my new AI book, go here:



Of related interest

https://newspaperdesign.in/ai-is-the-next-big-media-revolutionmario-garcia/

Newsrooms around the planet have gone mobile-first after a Garcia Media workshop!

Our Garcia Media Mobile Storytelling workshops are proven to introduce your editorial team to the way we write, edit and design for mobile platforms. It is a one-day program that involves a presentation (where I summarize my Columbia University class content), and follow it with a hands on workshop.

Did you read The Story yet?

I urge you to consult my latest book, The Story, a trilogy full of tips and explanations about mobile storytelling, which represents the latest genre for journalists to explore. See information below:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is trilogy-1024x762.png

The full trilogy of The Story now available–3 books to guide you through a mobile first strategy. Whether you’re a reporter, editor, designer, publisher, corporate communicator, The Story is for you! https://amazon

Volume 1: Transformation

https://books.apple.com/us/book/the-story-volume-i/id1480169411

Volume Two: Storytelling

https://books.apple.com/us/book/the-story-volume-ii/id1484581220

Volume Three: Design

https://books.apple.com/us/book/the-story-volume-iii/id1497049918

Order the print edition of The Story, from Amazon, here:

https://www.amazon.com/Story-I-Transformation-Mario-Garcia/dp/0578495759/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=The+Story+by+Mario+Garcia&qid=1565262220&s=gateway&sr=8-1) amazon.com/Story-I-Transf…

The Story, en español:

TheMarioBlog post #3383

The Mario Blog