The Mario Blog
The firing of the FBI Director on Page One

It’s the type of news that stuns, surprises and gets the adrenalin flowing for editors in newsrooms everywhere. On Tuesday, May 9, a news of such magnitude happened: President Trump fired the director of the F.B.I., James B. Comey, abruptly . Let’s look at how the front pages covered the monumental event.

This is a special edition of TheMarioBlog and will remain posted until Friday morning, May 12.

We always prepare for such news events. In some newsrooms, it is called “a 9/11” the day that is not another ordinary day in the news.

That’s exactly the type of day it was Tuesday, May 9, when President Trump fired the director of the F.B.I., James B. Comey, abruptly. while Comey himself was in Los Angeles, unaware of his firing, conducting a session with his Los Angeles FBI colleagues.

The news dominated online and TV news the rest of Tuesday evening and into the morning of Wednesday.  That is why I continue to be surprised that so many of the printed newspapers I have seen, courtesy of, did not take the opportunity to amplify the story on the headline. As you can see in the selection here, most of them simply said something to the effect that “Trump fires FBI Director”.

What makes this news significant, among other things, is that the fired FBI Director was the the top official leading a criminal investigation into whether Mr. Trump’s advisers colluded with the Russian government to steer the outcome of the 2016 presidential election.

Best headline by far

Let’s take a look at the pages.  I think that the Florida newspaper, tbt, published by the Tampa Bay Times, in St. Petersburg,Florida, had the winning headline. Why?

Because it is about the only newspaper I saw that played on the second day angle of the story. This is how print can get ahead, by  seducing readers with a headline that does not smell like yesterday’s news.

How the classics did it

Here is how the classically designed, “national”  newspapers handled the story:

By the way, here is an interesting piece on how the Times went about changing its front page to accommodate the Comey bombshell story.

The New Yorker treatment

Finally, a headline that advances the story beyond what we knew the moment the firing of Comey happened.


Bold and all caps

Many editors decided to pull all the stops with headlines in bold, all capital letters.

The “You’re Fired” brigade

Of course, there were those headline writers who could not resist the bait: to use the phrase made famous by Donald Trump in his reality show, The Apprentice, when he was a TV celebrity.



Those fun, irreverent tabloids


The most elegant presentation: Virginian Pilot

These guys always do such an exquisite job. They’ve done it again.


The ones who downplayed the story a bit



And the rest……most of them with exactly the same headline.



Meanwhile, the online heads were quite big too…..




Most interesting crop of the Comey photo: The Daily Beast



Speaking Engagements Coming Up

SIPConnect 2017, to be held in Miami June 21-23, is a program of the Inter American Press Association, IAPA, or SIP (Sociedad Interamericana de Prensa).  The venue will be the Hilton Miami Downtown Hotel.


Join us at the SIPConnect Hemispheric Conference 2017. Organized by the IAPA, SIPConnect is a gathering of media and digital businesses to encourage more audiences and higher revenues. It’s a laboratory for new ideas and successful experiences for the digital transformation. As in the 2016 successful meeting that was attended by media from the US, Latin America and the Caribbean, experts in digital businesses and representatives of innovative companies will participate in this event.

For more information



TheMarioBlog post #2624


Blog Post01.22.2018—1am
Are we using better photos today?
Blog Post01.19.2018—1am
The challenge of that fold
Blog Post01.18.2018—1am
The Washington Post: another profitable year
Blog Post01.17.2018—1am
Did I really read that much?
Blog Post01.15.2018—4am
The Guardian changes more than just the format
Blog Post—1am
Are vulgar words now part of a journalist’s styleguide?
Blog Post01.12.2018—4pm
The new New York Times campaign
Blog Post01.11.2018—1am
The good news about paying for content
Blog Post01.08.2018—3pm
Prof. Miguel Urabayen (1926-2018): Tribute to a grand maestro
Blog Post—2pm
Fire & Fury: Here’s a cover that tells more of the story
Blog Post—1am
End of print edition for Montreal’s La Presse
Blog Post01.07.2018—11am
Happy New Year…..I am back, sort of
Blog Post12.19.2017—10am
My prediction for 2018: we will write, edit & design for mobile
Blog Post12.13.2017—1am
Best wishes for the holiday season!
Blog Post12.12.2017—1am
Every year should be year of the audience
Blog Post12.11.2017—1am
The Post Most: curated content as easy as 1-2-3
Blog Post12.08.2017—1am
The power of a comic
Blog Post12.07.2017—1am
Those European ePapers Continue Growing
Blog Post12.06.2017—1am
Journalism students and print (not a romance)
Blog Post12.05.2017—1am
The nuances of using ragged right type
Blog Post12.04.2017—1am
Monocle’s habit-forming daily briefing
Blog Post12.01.2017—1am
2018: More digital everything, more of the Trump factor
Blog Post11.30.2017—1am
That time of the year to think what next
Blog Post11.29.2017—1am
Apple goes romantic
Blog Post11.28.2017—1am
E-mail newsletters can be a real seductive hook
Blog Post11.27.2017—8am
An e-newsletter with visual appeal
Blog Post11.21.2017—1am
So 2017 was really NOT the year of video……
Blog Post11.20.2017—1am
The New York Times: the Spanish weekly
Blog Post11.17.2017—5am
Paywalls, storytelling highlight Latin American conference
Blog Post11.15.2017—5am
In Argentina: the hot topic is “paywalls”
Blog Post11.14.2017—1am
The NY Times’ Jobs Classified: Really?
Blog Post11.13.2017—1am
At The New York Times: a kids section on Sunday
Blog Post11.10.2017—12am
“I read it on Facebook.”
Blog Post11.09.2017—12am
The flow of a breaking new story in the mobile era
Blog Post11.08.2017—12am
When content hits the spot
Blog Post11.07.2017—12am
When hierarchy makes a statement
Blog Post11.06.2017—12am
When the advertising wraps around
Blog Post11.03.2017—1am
New Hebrew fonts from Typotheque
Blog Post11.02.2017—1am
Favorite branding logos? No surprises
Blog Post11.01.2017—7am
A New York terrorist attack on the front pages
Contact us with speaking requests, questions or to discuss a project.