The Mario Blog
Modular vs. non-modular design: the conversation continues

TAKEAWAY: Today we post another craft-oriented blog, this time about a question that popped up last week during discussions with one of the editors in a current project. Should a newspaper follow a totally modular design?

Updated Tuesday, April 14, 1:39 pm EST

Mario Garcia Jr’s new blog post:

blog post image

How ESPN Chicago sticks another nail in the newspaper coffin … and what to do about it

Should a newspaper follow a totally modular design?

blog post image
The perfectly modular Hartford Courant

blog post image
Before modular design: the many-directional front page

blog post image
Detroit News from the 50s: banner headline that drops into one of the columns below it, but supports many other headlines under it as well

blog post image
LIFE section front of USAToday its first day of publication: Notice how Grace Kelly lead piece does not follow a module

blog post image
Brazilian newspapers, including Folha de Sao Paulo, disregard modules for a more imperfectly symmetrical style

Not that the answer to the question will in any way help financially strapped newspapers worldwide, but it is one of those perennially present topics when one gets down to the details of how a page is put together.

Last week, while working with the newspaper Sudkurier, in Konstanz, Germany, one of the editors reacted to my suggestion that a sports page be more dynamic by “breaking away” from the totally modular, perfectly square look.

“But, are you changing your mind about modules?,” he asked.

My answer is not at all.

“Your Contemporary Newspaper Design book specifically tells us about the virtues of modules,” he continued.

Indeed, but that was 1977, and I don’t wear the suits and ties that I wore then. We all evolve, and God knows newspapers have evolved a lot since the 1970s, when color was introduced, design became the “it” word in newsrooms, and advertising and classified were bringing in the cash, thank you.

Of course, I am in favor of modules. More importantly, I am in favor of using a GRID to design any page, or screen, for that matter. Grids help us get a sense of balance, proportion and visual organization on a page or screen. Grids are a network of uniformly placed horizontal and vertical lines for locating
points by means of coordinates.

However, one may follow a perfect grid on a page, and DEVIATE from it slightly to introduce a non-rectangular shape, which in the case of the sports page in question, would have allowed a dynamic, moving photo to go five columns across, while the headline and story under it would be only four.

Modules and newspaper design

Perhaps the modular design fever took off when Frank Ariss introduced a perfectly modulized design for the Minneapolis Tribune in the 1970s. Ariss also made Helvetica protagonist in his design, and adhered fully to a a Swiss grid. This was, indeed, revolutionary for newspapers everywhere, but, especially in the United States where most dailies still followed the 1950s model of “page make up”, which roughly translated into fill the page as you go, with stories and photos as interlocking pieces of a big text-driven puzzle.

With the Tribune’s new look, editors turned their attention to visual organization, perfect squares or “news units” on the page. Out went the so called dog legs of the past, or the awful armpits of another era, when a headline ran across the top of the page, with a thick black rule under it, to separate it from all the other non related stories and photos that hung from it like clothes on a line we may see at the top of a residential building in the teeming neighborhoods of Hong Kong.

The orchestrated non modular look

So I told the German editor: we can keep a perfectly modular page all the way, except for that one item where we break away from it, and the page gains in the process. More dynamic, more visual tension and a photo that is given its proper size treatment.

And there is nothing new here, it was that very visionary newsapper, USA Today, that brought back the dog leg and the armpit in 1985, right on the front page. Its design is full of energy, short items, small photos, and the only way to make all of that work was to deviate from the 100% modular look. USA Today continues to pull it off remarkably well everyday. But, for those of you studying USA Today pages, notice that the nonmodular effect is achieved with ONE element, not with many, which would result in visual chaos.

blog post image

The following links from today’s IFRA Executive News Service appear to be of special interest

IFRA Conference: Managing Ink and Paper
26–27 May, Hamburg
More information:

– Is The iPhone The New Newspaper?

– USA: Marriott to discontinue paper delivery

– USA: Honolulu Star-Bulletin unveils new compact format

– Germany: Bild publisher wants websites to pay for news

– Print is still king: Only 3 percent of newspaper reading happens online

Amazon Plans Big-Screen Kindle

– How can newspapers help Google?

– Arianna Huffington and Tom Curley: Journalism biz models for future

– An After-Life for Newspapers

– WSJ & the Kindle: Puzzling Relationship

– Time to Reinvent Advertising, Not Sabotage It

– Papers Try to Get Out of a Box

– Newspapers suffering in Europe, too

– ‘Hyperlocal’ Web Sites Deliver News Without Newspapers

:blog post image
To read TheRodrigoFino blog, in Spanish, go:

TheMarioBlog posting #238

Blog Post06.27.2017—12am
Goldman Sachs and the economics of design
Blog Post06.26.2017—1am
Trump, lies and storytelling
Blog Post06.23.2017—1am
Here’s Exchange, the new Frere-Jones font: it projects calm, authority
Blog Post06.22.2017—1am
The word “redesign” should be retired
Blog Post06.21.2017—1am
IAPA’s Digital Summit 2017 opens today in Miami
Blog Post06.20.2017—1am
Senior citizens read news on their mobile platforms! Surprise!
Blog Post06.19.2017—1am
Italy: we create new logo for The Post Internazionale
Blog Post06.16.2017—1am
Forget the one headline fits all theory!
Blog Post06.15.2017—1am
Change in newsroom goes beyond just a protocol statement
Blog Post06.14.2017—12am
Telling the story with just quotes
Blog Post06.13.2017—12am
How US front pages displayed the Comey story
Blog Post06.12.2017—12am
Making those complicated Washington political stories more visually interesting.
Blog Post06.09.2017—1am
Attracting young audiences (2)–Snapchat Discover
Blog Post06.08.2017—1am
Montreal’s La Presse+ says adieu to print!
Blog Post06.07.2017—1am
Attracting those younger readers (1): one gift subscription at a time
Blog Post06.06.2017—1am
The battle for your ears
Blog Post06.05.2017—1am
Quick ways to tell stories
Blog Post06.02.2017—1am
Garcia Media turns 25!
Blog Post06.01.2017—1am
It’s social media the publisher
Blog Post05.31.2017—1am
Before you get the room, read the Airbnb Magazine
Blog Post05.30.2017—1am
It’s a new homepage for The Atlantic
Blog Post05.26.2017—1am
New book: Designing for Touch
Blog Post05.25.2017—1am
Medium redesigns homepage: curated content is the key
Blog Post05.24.2017—1am
It’s the new storytelling, the new editing, the new design
Blog Post05.23.2017—1am
Millennials and their obsession with their phones—publishers, take note!
Blog Post05.22.2017—1am
Spiegel Daily: the German magazine’s new product
Blog Post05.19.2017—1am
Another day, another Trump bombshell for the front pages
Blog Post05.18.2017—1am
From digital to print: another example
Blog Post05.16.2017—6am
Trump bombshell news lands on the front pages
Blog Post—1am
For The Guardian: one contributor at a time
Blog Post05.15.2017—1am
The New York Times banks on kids: never too early!
Blog Post05.12.2017—1am
Good guide to e-newsletters that catch the reader’s attention
Blog Post05.10.2017—2pm
The firing of the FBI Director on Page One
Blog Post—1am
Sarasota Herald Tribune gets new look
Blog Post05.08.2017—8am
The Macron victory in France through the front pages
Blog Post—1am
Tony Awards: And the winner so far…..
Blog Post05.05.2017—1am
And now Dubai has its own font!
Blog Post05.04.2017—7am
The NYTimes’ Sketchbook: great visual solutions
Blog Post05.03.2017—1am
The luxury of paper
Blog Post05.02.2017—1am
Trump: 100 days and the front pages
Contact us with speaking requests, questions or to discuss a project.