The Mario Blog
11.30.2011—11am
Magazine apps need more of the tablet rich experience–not less

TAKEAWAY: The tablet is one of the best things that has happened to storytelling because it allows for media rich experiences that are essential to fulfilling the user’s expectations. So why are some magazine publishers describing these experiences as mere “bells and whistles”?

TAKEAWAY: The tablet is one of the best things that has happened to storytelling because it allows for media rich experiences that are essential to fulfilling the user’s expectations. So why are some magazine publishers describing these experiences as mere “bells and whistles”?

UPDATE #1: Tampa, Fla., 1:01 p.m.—SPD conversation

blog post image

Join the dialog on the SPD site as well: http://www.spd.org/2011/11/does-one-size-fit-all-lets-dis.php

Oh, no, tell me this isn’t true.

A recent report from adweek.com carries a headline that was enough to stop me for sure: Magazines Pull Back on Tablet Bells and Whistles: Why It’s Back to Basics for Some Publishers

The report quotes various magazine publishers saying things like rich-media features (I call them experiences) are “a secondary benefit,” or are “distracting, cause confusion, and occasionally irritate customers if the execution is not perfect.”

Funny that I would read this report on the same Tuesday that I have picked up my grandson Frankie from pre-school and brought him home with me for about three hours till my daughter picks him up in the afternoon. We follow our routine of fixing a quick lunch and then turning our attention to the ever popular iPad. Frankie is 4, but very iPad savvy, as are most of the kids in his class. We have several apps that we experience together, all related to children’s books. We have the more linear (less media rich) apps, and we have the ones that allow for greater interactivity—coloring the train cars in Thomas the Train, or doing puzzles, or doing things that keep the finger happy. There is no question about it: Frankie ASKS for the ones with the greater, more fun, enhanced experiences. I might as well delete the more linear ones.

Of course, Frankie is a young boy and these are not news/magazine apps. I am aware.

But the experience, the expectation, the total involvement between tablet and user is one where the richer and more substantial the role that the eye, the brain and the finger play, the happier the users are.

“It’s deja vu to web 1.0 all over again for magazines. Its startling that they see interactivity as a bell and whistle. When publishers truly embrace the tablet platform, they will see success,” says creative director, AOL Mobile, and president of the Society of Publication Designers Board of Directors Josh Klenert.

The research: more interactivity is the key

blog post image
Courtesy: http://rww.readwriteweb.netdna-cdn.com/images/bbcstudy_3.jpg

At any age. In whatever circumstance. Indeed, a recent BBC.com and Starcom MediaVest survey indicates that tablet users are eager for more interaction, not less. 85% of the 1,099 respondents were very or somewhat interested in “[m]ore tablet-specific content that allows [them] to interact with news stories in a hands-on way.”

This is why I cannot imagine that depriving apps from the richer, more interactive and fun experiences is the way to go.

Quite the contrary. We need to advance towards the 5.0 apps, rich in everything that extends the story, that provides the finger with tons to do, and which reminds us of all that a tablet can do that print or online can’t.

Bells and whistles? I would not use the phrase. I prefer to call them “pop ups”, and I include them among the essentials of what designing an app is all about—especially for magazines.

I would like to think that all of the smart people quoted in the Adweek.com piece are discussing a transitional or temporary situation.

No need for a pop up a minute: make smart choices about pop ups

blog post image
Frankie enjoys interactivity with his iPad apps

I remind my newspaper clients that it is not necessary to have 25 pop ups in any one daily edition of their newspaper. BUT they have to sit down and identify the three or four stories each day where pop ups are needed and strive to create them.

The same should apply to a magazine app. We do not want the perhaps overwhelming experience of a pop up at every turn, but intelligent magazine apps will provide those moments when the story demands it and presents the opportunities. We do not need to gyrate type gratuitously simply because it can be done. But we need to look for those visual opportunities where the pop up contributes to more effective storytelling.

Finally, and the reason I refuse to use the phrase “bells and whistles,” the tablet is a multi-genre platform: one reads, one sees, one hears, one watches videos. It is the combination of these genres that make for a satisfied user.

A well-designed magazine app does not have to be Disney World, Las Vegas or Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Instead, it has multi-sensory appeal, enhances stories and provides for the type of fun and enjoyment that Frankies of all ages appreciate.

Of related interest:

-More bells and whistles, please!
http://joezeffdesign.com/more-bells-and-whistles-please/

TheMarioBlog post #903
Blog Post09.26.2017—1am
Three things that caught our eye
Blog Post09.25.2017—1am
Paywalls & newspapers: from leaky to hard ones, and in between
Blog Post09.22.2017—4am
Mexican earthquake: front pages tell the story
Blog Post09.21.2017—1am
Saying adios to The Village Voice in print
Blog Post09.20.2017—1am
Vogue in print: “point of view, attitude”
Blog Post09.19.2017—1am
The Boston Scene
Blog Post09.18.2017—1am
Thoughts on print: still here, still full of surprises, worthy of attention
Blog Post09.15.2017—1am
New report: For publishers, Facebook is no revenue panacea
Blog Post09.14.2017—1am
Smartphones and web traffic: where the action is
Blog Post09.13.2017—1am
Paris Match: a good visit and big plans
Blog Post09.12.2017—1am
Irma: the morning after
Blog Post09.11.2017—3am
Irma: the bad girl on every front page
Blog Post09.08.2017—1am
Type Magazine: the new Roger Black project
Blog Post09.06.2017—1am
Linear storytelling for mobile: a good example
Blog Post09.05.2017—1am
For Le Journal de Montreal: article page acts like home page, sort of
Blog Post09.01.2017—1am
Facebook the new front page?
Blog Post08.31.2017—1am
When it comes to news, “designer labels” can make the difference
Blog Post08.30.2017—1am
Those fabulous print glossy ads
Blog Post08.29.2017—1am
From here and there: what the email basket brings
Blog Post08.28.2017—1am
Why I would show this Times Mag cover to my class
Blog Post08.24.2017—1am
A caricature for the ages
Blog Post08.23.2017—1am
It was the day Americans looked up!
Blog Post08.22.2017—1am
It was all about the solar eclipse of the century
Blog Post08.21.2017—1am
A day without local news? In Minnesota, readers experience it
Blog Post08.18.2017—1am
The good news about print (in the USA)
Blog Post08.17.2017—1am
What’s your lead story right this minute?
Blog Post08.16.2017—1am
Panama’s La Prensa: workshop digital media, day 2
Blog Post08.15.2017—1am
Panama’s La Prensa: digital workshop
Blog Post08.14.2017—1am
Millennials still like their Facebook
Blog Post08.11.2017—1am
All about the Eclipse: the Times nailed it.
Blog Post08.10.2017—1am
It’s the Monocle printed newspaper again
Blog Post08.09.2017—1am
Who pays for news, and who believes the news? Report tells us
Blog Post08.08.2017—1am
Workshops: linear visual storytelling
Blog Post08.07.2017—1am
For newspaper print editions: the power of the headline
Blog Post08.04.2017—1am
Behold the iPad: it’s still part of the media quintet
Blog Post08.03.2017—1am
At the NYTimes: push for customized content moves forward
Blog Post08.02.2017—1am
The Mooch’s quick departure on the front pages
Blog Post08.01.2017—1am
At The New York Times: aggressively pushing digital subscriptions
Blog Post07.31.2017—1am
Thoughts while on vacation
Blog Post07.14.2017—1am
Local newspapers, new digital strategies that work
Contact us with speaking requests, questions or to discuss a project.